The Studio Ghibli Mafia Game! - TOWN WINS!

Arix

@Sylandra you forgot ordassa's vote

Sylandra

Ordassa said:

@Sylandra is this allowed?

Vote Arix

Sorry, missed that! Edited earlier vote count to account for it.

Yarith

Vote: Ordassa

I'll probably rescind this sooner/later but for a lack of absolutely anything else to do or discuss, we might as well get some kind of confirmation on the tracker claim.

Yarith

(Also I'm still relatively new to mafia, I just read back and saw Tremula call it a watcher but I thought it was called a tracker earlier. Whatever it is.)

Ordassa

@Portius what did this power do to you?

Sylandra

Vote Count:
@Ordassa: Shaddus, Arix, Yarith (3)
@Arix: Ordassa (1)

With 15 alive, it's 8 to reach a majority lynch.

Mob Mentality is in effect:
Based on the current votes, @Ordassa will be lynched at the end of the dayphase.

(Day Two will end at 5pm EST on Sunday, 10/1, or when a majority lynch is reached.)

Ordassa

I see a who but not a what.

Lehki

Portius already stated that he didn't feel it was necessary to explain what the power was at this point, and I'm inclined to agree with him. We don't need to be outting powers this early on, it just gives mafia too much info to work with.

Ordassa

good point @Lehki. Well then, I will refrain from singing like a canary for the now.

Tremula

The main distinction between a watcher and a tracker is that a watcher chooses someone and sees everyone that acts on them, but generally not HOW they're acted upon. A tracker chooses a person, and follows them to see whom they act upon, but once again not how they act upon the target.

saobutt

I'm very conflicted on what to think from this discussion. Would it not be a good idea to wait until the next night to see what else Ordassa can track/watch before we decide on what to do with her? 
(I'm a really new to mafia and I the watcher/tracker thing seems useful?)

Ordassa

Ordassa is a male character.

Tremula

@saobutt, if we do let Ordassa live it is not likely they will get another night. As Lehki as said, Portius should not say what power was enacted upon him, because if he does and Ordassa confirms such a thing, then we have two town powers outed. Right now, it appears people want to pressure Ordassa to try and confirm the tracker information, which he has not yet confirmed.

So once again, @Ordassa, if you'd like some heat off of your back, please say very clearly who you saw get targetted. At this point I think it's Portius, from how Ordassa's been pressing him for information, and I'll keep my thoughts on that to myself for now.

Ordassa

@Tremula psh! as you say i am dead either way. if i sing, i am dead for sure. i will wait a little longer. then we are all down two. less protection for the rest

Sidd

That doesn't make sense, if you're dead either way and you are town, doesn't it make sense to give us as much information as possible before you die?

Ess

You are not dead either way @Ordassa.

First you have to give people a reason to keep you alive.

Second you must give them a reason to keep you alive.

If you are what you say you are, yours is a role worth keeping. So now you have to prove it

Tremula

@Ordassa, since you're new to mafia I'll explain the thought process. 

You are currently a dead man walking, by both town and mafia standards. You are not being of incredible use of town, giving us a safe lynch. However, if we choose to focus on someone else for the remainder of the day phases then it's likely the mafia will kill you tonight to have your power out of the way and to prevent you from accidentally seeing something useful.

However, if you become of use to the town by giving us as much information as is safe to do (which I have asked for twice now very clearly) then it is likely that you, as one of the likely-townies and likely-to-give-us-more-info-players will find a town protective power on you, should one exist. Ess is correct, Sidd is correct. Just tell us who was acted upon so they can confirm whether or not they received a night message of any sorts. Otherwise, you'll be lynched.

Ess

Those two reasons may be the same. Firstly i should add today. And secondly I should have added in future

Yarith

Thanks for clearing that up @Tremula.

Ordassa

@Tremula you've convinced me

yes it was@Portius

Kaimanahi

I'm so lost.

Portius

Ordassa said:

@Tremula you've convinced me

yes it was@Portius

Are you saying that you targeted me with a power that let you see who I targeted last night, or that you saw someone who used their power on me? The distinction is important.

Shaddus

I'm doubtful that Ordassa got lucky enough to target Portius with a power on the very night Portius is apparently targetted. Either Ordassa''s power is passive, or he's full of it

Ordassa

Nope @Shaddus I am not full of it. I know who targetted him and I rather not say because it would out another. Luck would be seeing who killed ponyo.

Arix

sounded like a vague statement that got amended when someone mentioned that they got targeted by something

Arix

It's like when a psychic says 'I'm sensing a loved one whose name starts with... T?' and someone in the audience jumps up and goes 'Yes! My husband's name was Thomas!'

Ordassa

I didnt target Portius. never said I did. I slipped into the pocket of the eprson who hit portius with a power

Ordassa

@Portius was what you got hit with a blocker?

Portius

Ordassa said:

@Portius was what you got hit with a blocker?

Do we want me to provide this information? I can do it if there's a compelling reason, but I'm not seeing what it could confirm if Ordassa only watched the person who targeted me.

Yarith

Unvote, Vote:Nobody

I'm going to be honest, I'm a little lost.