It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
I really hate being the doctor, also something that bugged me was having a bomber and nobody who could detect/remove bombs. Actually, just gonna ask @Lehki now: If I had used my power on someone whose bomb would have gone off that night, what would have happened?
You are right, Vigilante is a town role, but you know what a vigilante does? They kill people. You know what scum does? They kill people. Two different roles that can perform the same power? Say it ain't so!You know, kind of like the Investigator/Consigliere comparison. Scum doesn't get investigators, they get consigliere's, but for some reason, consigliere's can claim to be an investigator despite the fact that investigator is a town only role. Weird how that happens.By your argument, you can't claim a town only power with any sort of credibility but somehow investigator (a town only role) can be claimed and you even made that argument!Here's how I could have foreseen it going. 'Hey, I'm <insert safe claim name here> and I can kill people using <safe claim tool/power/whatever because Tremula's role reveal showed that you can use your safe claim's powers to give you credibility> so I'm a vigilante, instead of just a regular ol' scum killing people, like scum do.' The flavor fit, the evidence that this was a possible fit, I'm not sure why you think your claim should have somehow been ironclad without any reason to doubt it just because you used the word 'Vigilante'
So your argument now is mafia had a secondary kill not called Vigilante, which is fairly normal, but that having this secondary kill was enough for the mafia to assume the town didn't have a Vigilante, thus making Vigilante a safe bluff. You've completely lost me where the mafia can make the leap from "we have a secondary kill" to "bluff Vigilante, the town doesn't have one."That makes even less sense. I already explained why Vigilante is not a good mafia bluff unless they know the town doesn't have one. Your counter was I could know, because I could have the power named in my role like Tremula did. You're disregarding the single most relevant point. The role name is important. I didn't give a vague kill people claim, I claimed the role itself. It's super simple. There are roles mafia can blindly claim, be vague, and play the odds. "I AM THE VIGILANTE," is not among them.Going in circles at this point, so it is what it is. I maintain it was a terrible play.
So your argument now is mafia had a secondary kill not called Vigilante, which is fairly normal, but that having this secondary kill was enough for the mafia to assume the town didn't have a Vigilante, thus making Vigilante a safe bluff. You've completely lost me where the mafia can make the leap from "we have a secondary kill" to "bluff Vigilante, the town doesn't have one."
I am shocked to hear that the night two cluster was even more complicated than we thought. Sidd never let us land anything where we meant to early game. A lot of nighttime story coordination went to waste!
You’re lucky I was dead, buddy! I had your number the moment Yasei flipped third party after you were suspiciously oh so sure he was Town. (Though tbf watching you kill me only confirmed that suspicion loool)