You don't know the full context of that out-of-context email wherein the writer was told specifically why it was rejected but after multiple back and forth, this was presented as the bottom… (View Post)
As you well know, this email had nothing to do with lore or canon and was over an issue about a writing that was deemed not to be appropriate because of a sexual nature. My point to you was that in s… (View Post)
Yes, I believe any who use an out-of-context email to be ashamed of using it as an argument for anything (which your number 3 point does, ahem). Yes, I should take a breather, so I won't be looking a… (View Post)
Could perhaps someone give an example of a scholarly book that was rejected for lack of evidence? My understanding is that it is extremely rare to reject a book, that it is more often for being OOC, … (View Post)