How many spectators did we have? Like obviously anyone can check in, but if I'd realized so many people were watching with interest I probably would have been more nervous about looking dumb!
(Quote)
Given how contentious no-lynch was on Day 1, I actually thought no-kill seemed like a pretty reasonable guess, forcing us to fight amongst ourselves even longer.
Yeah, it's just a possible answer. It's not what I'm confidently claiming happened. I have no way of knowing what someone being blocked by the fortune would actually look like. I've still been thinking of it as a way to ensure a key user's success m…
(Quote)
Quoting this for relevancy. The vote can't be undone at this point. And it's not hard for Siam to have overlooked this post -- Luce did too, after all. Still, while it's not the most suspicious thing in the world, I do kind of w…
I'm not sure the jail would prevent the vision -- especially since a vision of Shaddus is exactly what Ssaliss claimed. But that's moot, since 4 clinches it.
Extra vote Ssaliss just so it's unanimous. Time to all walk forward toge…
If Siam is scum, I'd be very surprised. While I guess there's nothing explicitly town about the vision role and we could have gotten by without it, it's still been consistently used and helpful.
...I stand by the Ssaliss vote, but I'm going to Unvote for now since we haven't had any input from Siam, and I don't want the day to end without a chance for more input.
I made a then/than error and can't edit the post. Please send help.
Ssaliss's aggression towards Shaddus has been a little strange and uncalled for, and I've said as much earlier in the game. I made an argument long ago as to why I though…
(Quote)
Assuming they knew they were attacked at all, though. Which, to be fair, they might have! So yeah, you would have been putting yourself in danger without too much reason.
So yeah, I think the attack is too difficult to verify, b…
The earlier attack is really hard to verify at this point. We know something happened, but we don't actually know who it involved. When the day was first starting, I even thought it was possible that someone had tried to kill Celina, since that was …
(Quote)
I'll ask this again: given the limitation of only being able to target a person once the entire game, why is it suspicious that I'd be conservative and not use it every single night during the early game?
Yeah, I'll switch my vote to Luce, as all this makes sense to me.
On the duplication of roles, I'd mention that as more details were revealed about my power, I tried really hard to use the words "immunity" and "fortune" rather than…
(Quote)
If there is indeed one and only one scum remaining, it's impossible that it was me. Sylandra would know that for certain, whatever Sylandra's allegiance winds up being.
Oh, and obvious post script: if Sylandra comes on while I'm asleep and claims to have not been visited by my statue, then Sylandra is the scum. But otherwise I'm resting my hopes that I made the right call.
At the very least, scum killing Saran makes me genuinely look suspicious, so I can at least respect the decision to lynch me today if it happens. Saran's logic was flabbergastingly stupid, so lynching me yesterday would have left me a bit peeved.
Anyways, since I used my power on Sylandra last night, even if I am scum, there must be at least one more besides me. If my scumminess is so guaranteed, I'm utterly harmless -- I can be blocked, jailed, and so on on the upcoming magical 7th night. S…
It's 3 a.m. and I really need to sleep so I'll just rattle off everything that comes to mind that might be relevant, after which the vote will probably be decided either way before I wake up.
It was night 6. If Saran's theory was actually correct, no one would have died, because only Tarkenton can kill someone in multiples of 3. 6 is also divisible by 2, but Tremula's gone as well.
Not unexpected, really. Saran was probably the most obvious target after a public plan was formed, combined with an argument with another person so his death would immediately make the other person look suspicious.