Ushaara · Schrödinger's Traitor
Reactions
Comments
-
Lots of no power claims being made, which continues to make me less and less likely to believe Vivet was a vigilante kill. Still maintain that I would have been the vigilante's best target.
Vivet - Soulless
Selenity - S… -
Hmm, it's a good question.
I don't know Silvanus well enough to have any real insight into his thinking for how he assigns Elders to roles, but power-wise, I'd think the Traitor faction has some form of investigator to scout for converts,… -
Given Sylandra's different interpretation of Fain's rolesheet, I'd like to hear how others are interpreting it.
Started with multiple members, or Fain as standard cult recruiter?
I'm also putting my money on the Illith/Kethuru … -
@Sylandra You're an unexpected quasi-defender, but thank you for articulating how tricky my role and the scenario I'm in is. If I had tried to say anything more …
-
Anyhoo, it's getting late here, and I've felt this train a-coming from the beginning of this day-phase.
This time, I'm really out.
-
I'm inclined to believe Othero, since I think his information has been the best Town source, and nothing he has said has been disproven yet.
Kethuru/Illith fight Night 1? -> Only 1 death, also fits the SK Soulless idea.
Soulless … -
Please outline why you find Othero suspicious, @Shaddus?
-
I'm not nervous. I'm paranoid, but in this case, everyone -is- out to get me!
-
Man, it probably is the suspicion and paranoia of the game getting to me now, but @Weiwae I really feel like your behavior/opinion toward me changed the moment I v…
-
@Weiwae
(Quote) As I said before, timing of a reveal is everything in this game. Day 2, I had not revealed my power, and as it had not come to last resort st… -
One final final argument...
If Othero's information is true, we could have lost 3 people last night.
While yes, Fain/Vivet's death could have been a vigilante, why did the vigilante not target me? It would have yielded the bes… -
(Quote) One last response since I didn't notice this one come in.
In that case, I'm going to channel 'The Giver', and say "Precision of language!"
Tracker implies a very specific thing - that you see who the person targe… -
I don't know whether to be impressed or maddened by Silvanus here, because everything about my role is feeling like a diabolical game of chicken.
Chicken with the Soulless, on whether I activate my power or not.
Chicken with the rest… -
(Quote) Well the true answer to that is likely because I was asleep, and by the time I woke up, the argument had moved on.
But really, how do you think that would have went at the time?
"Err, it's a bad idea to investigate m… -
In an effort to finally put this canon/noncanon thing to bed...
(Quote) Things to note. Plurals, plurals, plurals. We. Group. Night chat. Other traitors. etc.
We've been assuming Forbidden Elixir is a cult recruitment thing, b… -
Again, that chaos was not of my making. I was expecting blowback, sure, but the chaos was caused as a result of the Weiwae/Sylandra argument and the lines that formed after.
Lynching me verifies canon/noncanon, certainly, but now given Sh… -
(Quote) I can't do anything about the role I got dealt, more than you can about yours. As I said, I'm a convenient fall guy, and if I'm lynched because of it, that's the way it goes.
I'm as tired of the debate around me as everyone… -
As I said, I'm assuming Traitor faction because it reads to me like feeding information to the Soulless faction groups. Best chance of a Traitor win is surviving as long as they can while Soulless kill townies. Revealing information such as he did i…
-
Okay, Shaddus' "corrected" claim is that he's a tracker, and so he should have seen who Yomo's target was.
I don't buy the tracker claim, since he should have been able to name Yomo's target. So he's a confirmed investigator through Sylan… -
Blergh, I'm still suspicious of Portius, but going to Unvote for now, and try think through Shaddus/Yomo.
If Othero was bussed, he wasn't jailed/blocked, so his Soulless Sense worked -> Selenity was targeted by a Soulless.
… -
Hnngh, just read Breandryn's argument again, and do think there's something fishy going on there now.
Two jailors doesn't seem likely. That Shaddus had claimed investigator made me think "maybe", and that powers were being duplicated so … -
This debate around my claim appears to be neverending and I see why people want to lynch me, just to shut it up. But I feel like (barring a few of you), it is the only thread some of you want to pull on, to the point where you're exaggerating what e…
-
Haha. Well you called Weiwae your Tekora earlier in the game, I'm thinking you're mine.
Anyway, I'm off to bed but still very suspicious of Portius.
-
(Quote) Hey, hey, hey. I don't know why you're blaming me for people claiming.
I challenged Selenity to explain how she survived the Soulless, given Othero's information which I thought made her a conversion candidate. I only asked… -
(Quote) How I'm reading the First Circle confusion:
End of day post was First Circle convening meeting. Power fluff mentions First Circle leave and meeting ends.
-> This does not mean Othero is First Circle.
Af… -
@Selenity are you First Circle?
Weiwae jails Othero bussed to Selenity
Yomo isolates Selenity bussed to Othero?
Bit of a bizarre fluke… -
And there goes my Dracnoris theory
-
Ah, well that would likely explain Selenity's survival.
Unvote
I'll be happy to switch to Sylandra/Portius.
-
Oh my gosh, Sylandra might be Traitor Manteekan? No wonder she's so keen to off me and establish her own towniness. Haha.
-
So if you're telling the truth, we have two protectors, or two jailors.
@ssaliss here is where a colour me suspicious is appropriate!
I do b…
(c) Iron Realms Entertainment 2012.