I think there's too many now, but you can always put me in a replacement pile and rotate me in if someone feels they can't play anymore. I'll be interested in this game regardless (I have a distant relative who was involved with the Manhattan Projec…
(Quote)
I think the real reason is that due to how the mafia role pages are written, it's very easy for them to just develop tunnel-vision for Mary. Then once Mary is gone, Elizabeth suddenly has an arson power. Given how the arson powe…
I'm just totally stumped, though. This is the first game I've played in months and I was hoping I could learn more to polish back up into shape, but I'm really clueless if I could have done …
(Quote)
You know, when you first accused Tekora, for a while I thought he could actually be Robert Dudley, and that you were William or someone else. If Tekora was in the mafia, it would have been a really brilliant move - then if eith…
When you hear the patter of footsteps approaching you, with a sinking feeling you discern that they aren't those of your loyal maid. No, these footsteps are louder, duller, each thud causing your heart to beat like a battering ram in your chest. Sti…
Insomnia's getting to me tonight and I can't get sleep, so since Synkarin's getting his dues I want to take a moment to say "nope" and give the limelight back to Allyrianne.
She did a very good job of playing up at being town wh…
(Quote)
That would have been an interesting twist! I think he just really didn't know what to do and was... I don't know, afraid I had some means of telling if he was lying/fakeclaiming? Anyways, if that's more what you'd have wanted to…
(Quote)
I've seen bomb on the head mafioso pretty often. They will, naturally, never reveal this and allow it to reveal itself. It's why waiting until late in the game to reveal you are a bomb is considered more of a scum move.
(Quote)
Of all the things I saw, this surprised me the most. I didn't doubt that Falmiis was a bomb, but I was quite sure he was scum and eliminating him sooner rather than later was key. The self-janitor cleaning was just the icing on …
(Quote)
Millers are a -strong- anti-town role, and I hope this game shows it to you! For every miller/pseudo-miller, you should pretend a town power doesn't exist, really. Once you do that, you'll start to see the shift.
Biggest regret for this game - not hammering it into people's heads that there was no good reason for Kiradawea to claim if she was SK. I just kind of mused over this not making sense. …
(Quote)
And town still lost! Having fewer mafia doesn't mean as much with that reality, and the added potential for a late game turncoat is quite a bit. Synkarin was totally on the rails and they still let him live over someone who name…
I'll wait until I see all the roles before I give my final assessment on game balance, but I think I'm more or less still where I was on my stance prior, Sylandra.
Ah, I had been expecting this for a while now, and was hoping Allyrianne would indeed be Queen Elisabeth and win. She played a strong game until the Lola claim, imo, which is where it started to get shaky... but luck was on her side anyways! Very we…
(Quote)
I don't know, at this point I'm throwing out ideas and seeing what will stick. I seriously just want an artifact to store other artifacts and allow direct access to them - that's all! The more I think about artifacts I'd still w…