(Quote)
Per my previous e-mail, people who use up a limited use-power would have read as vanilla to me. Actually, in case I get murdered tonight, my suggestion for tomorrow is Coraline because she is swinging for the fences trying to f…
(Quote)
We won't know whether Arix is vanilla town tomorrow if we don't lynch him today, because as previously discussed, the game will end by the end of N2 if no scum are eliminated and nobody is saved. You have to lynch today to see know whether …
I misunderstood my power, and it works during the day. People who have used their powers count as vanilla, as in the Cute Animal Mafia. I have used my power on Arix, and am 100% confident he is lying about being a vanilla townie. Lynch me tomorrow i…
The more I think about it, the less I buy Arix's lack of power. Both Portius's Arthur and Cute Animal mafia games ran with everyone having a single use power. Nobody started vanilla in either one. I'm pressing X to doubt.
I buy Sylandra's claim, but I am not clear enough on Alexandria's and Carakhan's claims to bet the farm on them being overlap instead of complementary.
I am also on board for mass-claim. In a show of good faith, I the Witchhunter, a limited investigator. My one-use power reports whether or not a target is a vanilla townie. Anyone with an ability or non-town will trigger it, but I will not know whic…
(Quote)
There's not going to be an actual reason. Nobody's had time to use their powers if they have them. The basis of a day-one lynch is that a 2/7 random chance of hitting scum is better than a 0/7 chance, and that analysis of the lynch to…
I would like to make a case for a day-one lynch this game. We have seven players. In terms of balance, we're on the threshold of a game appropriately sized for one or two scum. In terms of the math of a pure random guess probability, one scum would …
It sounds like there is consensus suspicion of Chronas. My believing him was on the basis of "This sounds like something Portius would make the basis of a power but obscure enough that it's a long-shot that a player would", but that's obviously not …
(Quote)
Sylandra already coveredwhat I'm going to say, but I figured I should answer to this directly anyway. I was the first to claim, and claimed investigator. That's a role that almost always exists, so it's an extremely high-risk move to …
(Quote)
Zero sympathy here. You signed up for the game and then disappeared for a couple of days. I know you're mad you get lynched, but that could have very easily been avoided if you had claimed and made your case. You had a power that soun…
(Quote)
Your reasoning behind staying cagey about night event feels pro-town to me. I am not hard sold on Chronas, but I don't think we're going to get anything more solid today unless we push for a mass claim. We've got to take a shot at a l…
(Quote)
I will absolutely riot if we no-vote today. If we vote today and we're wrong, we get one more shot to get it right tomorrow. If we skip today and get it wrong tomorrow, the game is over.
I'm going to claim as the investigator. I have memorized the great deeds of Arthur's Knights and can determine the allegiance of whoever I visit. I visited Arix last night to determine his
allegiance and can confirm him as town. My power's one…