I too am more suspicious of Kilee than Rolsand as a trainer. Let alone possibly being able to steal Pokemon from others, the possibility for her to actively expand her Pokemon squad means that she will become quite powerful with an arsenal of abilities at her disposal, and I'm not sure that I trust her to use them for the benefit of the town. If she's not with the town, then she probably becomes a target for the mafia. Vote: Kilee
I would probably encourage others to damage the Sandshrew as Celina has volunteered, so as to remove it from the equation.
... Am I the only one feeling a little bit sorry for the sandshrew? Here he is, following his trainer, being all loyal... which makes you all want to murder it in the face He just wants to be loved, damnit!
I'm ok with either Rolsand or Kilee for the lynch. I haven't decided which one is worth more. I'll vote one way or the other when I decide, but I need a little longer to cogitate. Probably not going outside that pair unless some new revelation reveals itself.
To that end, I have a question for the class. I haven't been able to figure out if Kilee claimed her pokemon-acquisition ability as a pokemon power or a trainer power. Does anyone know which is the case? I'm probably missing it in the gigantic mass of posts.
Any sufficiently advanced pun is indistinguishable from comedy.
Damn just as I was considering Unvoting people manage to reaffirm my suspicions.. sorry Rolsand but my vote stays. I feel it is too risky to keep you alive with an alternate win Condition.
@Potius the ability to find new pokemon is her Kecleons power, whether it is this same power that actually gives her a new pokemon or not is still in question.
The vote on Luce was essentially for him not speaking. Which reminds me...
0
SylandraJoin Queue for Mafia GamesThe Last Mafia Game
Now we're getting somewhere! Votes are excellent. We can use those in the future to draw conclusions and make speculations.
Opinion: if this day phase is any indication, many of us here will have OP Pokemanz. If every lynch we are forced to debate "is it safe to let this Pokemon exist" we might not lynch a damn person in this game. I also am willing to believe the town to mafia/third party ratio is in the town's favor, as is traditional. So barring Kilee stealing a Pokemon, odds are a townie will get it. And I'm thinking it's impossible for Kilee to avoid being targeted by someone tonight for something if she lives.
"Oh yeah, you're a naughty mayor, aren't you? Misfile that Form MA631-D. Comptroller Shevat's got a nice gemstone disc for you, but yer gonna have to beg for it."
@Makaela No, Ally voted that way because there hasn't been a check-in on Luce's part (without reasoning). She believes scum is succeeded in surviving by staying quiet.
Damn just as I was considering Unvoting people manage to reaffirm my suspicions.. sorry Rolsand but my vote stays. I feel it is too risky to keep you alive with an alternate win Condition.
Potius the ability to find new pokemon is her Kecleons power, whether it is this same power that actually gives her a new pokemon or not is still in question.
Did I somehow miss Luce being suspect?
Allyrianne voted for Luce because he's only posted once. I have mercy because his post was letting us know he's alive but rather ill. We're excusing people who haven't posted at all due to being away, so I don't see why we'd vote out a sick person.
Total posts. Also, Lavinya made two posts, and Alary have made none, just to clarify. Also, since posts come in way way way too quickly, it might be off a couple of posts of the latest before I made that list.
Hello everyone! Trainer Salome here, just getting back from a long respite in the Water Gym by the various beaches (you know the ones, I honestly have no idea). Thank you for being patient, fellow pokedex collectors and researchers! I am here, and I will not take a vote this day, because I have much to catch up on. However, going through the various pages I have missed, the nature of the game swings the vote negatively in Trainer Kilee's direction. @Melai, wanted to know of my intent, and there it is.
My pokemon, I can reveal is related to ice. I haven't spent much time with them, working on training and battling. But I'll get back to you all soon!
The apple is cold, crisp, and sour as the juices fill your mouth. As you consume the fruit, you glimpse, for a moment, a massive, shadowy figure, Her snow-white hair framing a perfect, icy-eyed visage. Beneath you, a vast, perfect web of silken strands lies - and, for a moment, you realize that you too are part of it, weaver and strand both - and home.
My reasoning for picking him over Kilee is as follows:
-Third parties worry me, especially in a high power game. Even if it's a case of a choice between winning as town or winning alone, there's a pretty big chance of betrayal over the course of the game.
-Posting style is leading to a lot of circular arguments and confusion. I'm concerned that it's going to distract people from other topics as more and more information piles up. It seems reasonable to nip it in the bud now.
-Low risk. Rolsand claimed third party and hasn't claimed any major powers beyond his pokemon, so I'm guessing he doesn't have any that strongly benefit the town. They probably would've come up by now. Even if he stays completely town-loyal for the whole game, he probably won't be much better than a vanilla townie. A wrong lynch on him is probably safer than a wrong lynch on Kilee.
-I'm willing to accept that Kilee can get more pokemon. I don't know if that means stealing them, capturing wild ones, or just getting first pick of salvage. I can easily see all of those existing. I'm not sure that I buy it as a pokemon ability as opposed to a trainer power, but I'm not ruling it out, and I can see a bunch of reasons why a town player would claim their trainer power as a pokemon power instead in her situation. The whole thing could be a bluff, but bluffing the ability to create more powers strikes me as so dangerous that it'd be an unlikely choice.
-If it is a pokemon power, then it's probably random assortment. The odds of a random pick favor it ending on with the town, and that's a really strong town power. If I'm correct in guessing that it's actually her trainer power, then we go into guessing if we think Tremula would put that on a scum or not. Intuition tells me that Tremula would put it on a town or a third party, but I could also see it on scum. I'm not confident in my intuition.
-If Kilee lives, she's probably getting investigated. We can lynch her tomorrow if she turns out to be evil. I don't think waiting a day will tell us much more about Rolsand, but Kilee
Any sufficiently advanced pun is indistinguishable from comedy.
By the power of subtraction, I have come up with the following list of posts since day 1 started + Ssaliss's post and onward. Some may have been missed. I gave up on rearranging the list.
(Without sounding like a snot...) I posted that so the Uninitiated won't latch on the idea that Kilee has Darkrai or something already. I highly doubt Darkrai will make an appearance, it's probably more the mascot for one of the two groups we're dealing with.
I agree with Portius - Kilee doesn't seem to have anything dangerous left (Shadow Sneak has a cooldown by her own admission).
Comments
I would probably encourage others to damage the Sandshrew as Celina has volunteered, so as to remove it from the equation.
To that end, I have a question for the class. I haven't been able to figure out if Kilee claimed her pokemon-acquisition ability as a pokemon power or a trainer power. Does anyone know which is the case? I'm probably missing it in the gigantic mass of posts.
Ixion tells you, "// I don't think anyone else had a clue, amazing form."
Opinion: if this day phase is any indication, many of us here will have OP Pokemanz. If every lynch we are forced to debate "is it safe to let this Pokemon exist" we might not lynch a damn person in this game. I also am willing to believe the town to mafia/third party ratio is in the town's favor, as is traditional. So barring Kilee stealing a Pokemon, odds are a townie will get it. And I'm thinking it's impossible for Kilee to avoid being targeted by someone tonight for something if she lives.
Allyrianne voted for Luce because he's only posted once. I have mercy because his post was letting us know he's alive but rather ill. We're excusing people who haven't posted at all due to being away, so I don't see why we'd vote out a sick person.
Make of that what you wish.
My pokemon, I can reveal is related to ice. I haven't spent much time with them, working on training and battling. But I'll get back to you all soon!
My reasoning for picking him over Kilee is as follows:
-Third parties worry me, especially in a high power game. Even if it's a case of a choice between winning as town or winning alone, there's a pretty big chance of betrayal over the course of the game.
-Posting style is leading to a lot of circular arguments and confusion. I'm concerned that it's going to distract people from other topics as more and more information piles up. It seems reasonable to nip it in the bud now.
-Low risk. Rolsand claimed third party and hasn't claimed any major powers beyond his pokemon, so I'm guessing he doesn't have any that strongly benefit the town. They probably would've come up by now. Even if he stays completely town-loyal for the whole game, he probably won't be much better than a vanilla townie. A wrong lynch on him is probably safer than a wrong lynch on Kilee.
-I'm willing to accept that Kilee can get more pokemon. I don't know if that means stealing them, capturing wild ones, or just getting first pick of salvage. I can easily see all of those existing. I'm not sure that I buy it as a pokemon ability as opposed to a trainer power, but I'm not ruling it out, and I can see a bunch of reasons why a town player would claim their trainer power as a pokemon power instead in her situation. The whole thing could be a bluff, but bluffing the ability to create more powers strikes me as so dangerous that it'd be an unlikely choice.
-If it is a pokemon power, then it's probably random assortment. The odds of a random pick favor it ending on with the town, and that's a really strong town power. If I'm correct in guessing that it's actually her trainer power, then we go into guessing if we think Tremula would put that on a scum or not. Intuition tells me that Tremula would put it on a town or a third party, but I could also see it on scum. I'm not confident in my intuition.
-If Kilee lives, she's probably getting investigated. We can lynch her tomorrow if she turns out to be evil. I don't think waiting a day will tell us much more about Rolsand, but Kilee